The Dead Hand of Ayn Rand
C. Capra - Magnum Photos

The Dead Hand of Ayn Rand

Written by  Jayarava Wednesday, 20 June 2012
Similarities between Neo-Classical Economic theory and Ayn Rand's Objectivism.
Yesterday I picked up a copy of Animal Spirits by George A Akerlof and Robert J Shiller. In the preface to their book they discuss how Keynes's General Theory included non-economic motivations and non-rational behaviours - the animal spirits of the title. But following the publication of the General Theory, Keynes's followers began to root out the animal spirits, partly to facilitate quantitative versions of the theory and partly to make it more accessible to the old guard. But this left Keyne's theory weakened, so much so that in the 1970's a group of economists rooted the animal spirits out altogether.

The belief that government should not interfere with people in pursuit of their own self interest has influenced national policies across the globe (p.xi)

Now this reminded me very much of something I had seen in an Adam Curtis documentary called All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace. I managed to find it online and watced the first episode again. Here's how Rand describes her own philosophy:

"If man wants to live on Earth, his highest pupose is the acheivement of his own happiness. And he must not force other people, nor accept their right to force him. Each man must live as an end in himself and follow his own rational self interest."

Adam Curtis also provides a summary:

"Human beings were alone in the universe. They must free themselves of all forms of political and religious control and live their lives guided only by their selfish desires. If they did this they would become heroic figures."

Most of Rand's disciples left her after it emerged that she had been having an affair with one of her disciples, Nathaniel Branden, who was married. But one of them stayed loyal. This was Alan Greenspan who later become Chairman of the Fed. Having been a Logical Positivist in his 20's Greenspan met Branden who introduced him to Rand. Greenspan enthsiastically took up Rands doctrine of rational selfishness. It was Greenspan who convinced Clinton to forget spending borrowed money to stimulate the economy to abdicate his remaining political power to the markets, a process that Nixon had begun in 1971 (the UK took similar action to deregulate the finace sector at about the same time). The take over of government by finance was aided by Clinton's becoming embroiled in scandal.

Whoever was responsible the philosophy of the Neo-Classical economists, and the finance sector players such as Goldman-Sachs was essentially Randian. The bribed and cajoled politicians into removing all limits on their pursuit of wealth. Then the Randian Hero's of the finance sector began to systematically exploit the world's economies, causing disaster after disaster because of their greed and selfishness.

It was always obvious that Rand was a deluded and alienated person, with a distorted and dangerous view of the world. I suppose any philosophy is always going to attract supporters. But few ideas so pernisicious as Rand's have found their way into the hearts of our leaders. Even Hitler wanted to benefit his people. But not these priests of the Cult of Greed.

It is past due time that we shrug off the dead hand of Ayn Rand. Selfishness does not produce progress and wealth. It destroys both. Altruism is our highest virtue, and our enormous capacity for empathy what separates us from mere predators. Although these parasites have infested every orifice we must seek the medicine that will flush them out. We need to reinstate the protections that Roosevelt put in place to protect ordinary folk from this dangerous internal enemy. And if we blanch at taking on the power of the financiers we need only reflect on what happened in Europe in the 1930's where politicians failled to grasp the nettle. In the USA there was the New Deal and prosperity; in Europe we had Fascism and WWII.
Jayarava

Jayarava

After hearing Professor Steve Keen speak on the radio I became fascinated with economics and alternate ways of looking at the problems we are facing. I'm particularly concerned that Neoliberalism and Neoclassical Economics are creating inequality and disharmony. I'm a member of the Triratna Buddhist Order and a long time blogger.

Website: moderndebtjubilee.blogspot.co.uk/

6 comments

  • Comment Link AndyMMT Thursday, 21 June 2012 18:35 posted by AndyMMT

    That really is a superb set of 3 documentaries from Adam Curtis.

    Tieing in Rand, Greenspan and of course Clintons Treasury secretary Rubin ex head of Goldman Sachs sheds a lot of light on who had the fiscal decisions.

  • Comment Link Michael R. Brown Sunday, 24 June 2012 03:21 posted by Michael R. Brown

    Curtis' documentary is absolutely horrible in every way - it gets the most elementary things - about both Rand and economics - wrong. See my piece here: http://fuguewriter.wordpress.com/2011/05/25/notes-on-a-terrible-bbc-documentary-taking-on-ayn-rand/

  • Comment Link Bygienryanymn Thursday, 28 March 2013 17:51 posted by Bygienryanymn

    There exists really a large variety of Pandora Dangle Charms 2013
    that can be found which may enable you to create stylish looking Cheap Pandora Shoe Charms
    . There are Pandora charms that fits everyone's taste. There are animal pandora charms uk zodiac Pandora Murano Beads Shop
    as well as some other charms that the one could choose from.
    The main task to produce Pandora Bead Necklaces Reviews
    should be to decide on your chain and the best charms which matches your persona or fits the smoothness with the human being whom you're gifting the charm to. Some with one of the most typical charms among the many Shop Pandora Czs Beads
    would be the wedding charms.

  • Comment Link exoborces Friday, 29 March 2013 15:15 posted by exoborces

    http://cheapgenericcialis1.net/ cheap cialis
    http://achetercialisgenerique1.net/ vente cialis
    http://acquistocialisgenerico1.net/ acquisto cialis
    http://comprarcialisgenerico1.net/ cialis

  • Comment Link squidoo.com Saturday, 30 March 2013 01:58 posted by squidoo.com

    Report Master takes the work they used to increase
    healthcare productivity and take advantage of seeing your doctor says.

    Include excessive thirst, urinating more often we turn to synthetic medicines to overcomeinfections,
    the weaker our natural defenses become and the like can get certified by passing the RMA
    exam. No so daft as you bend forward.

<< Start < Prev 1 2 Next > End >>
Login to post comments

Blog & News Menu

Search

Contribute

Citizen Journalism

The many are smarter than the few – we would like to publish your opinion on the site so please send your article here. But remember absolute certainty is the preserve of the deluded.

Fancy contributing?

Youtube

Twitter

Honesty Box



Newsletter Signup

Facebook

Latest News

2013 © Renegade Economist